Do You Really Deserve a Break Today?
McDonald’s turned the phrase, “You deserve a break today,” into marketing gold. The idea that we all work hard and deserve a treat was incredibly successful. You’ve heard it countless times in stores, as shoppers talk themselves into purchases. You’ve probably used this line yourself a few times. I know I have.
I doubt I ever will again, though, after a recent event. My mom started going through my grandmother’s journals a few weeks ago. These weren’t diaries of feelings and emotions. They were essentially a recording of the day’s events. What did my mom find out?
Did You Round up Any Livestock Today?
Grandma worked hard. Every day. For decades. She did it all, from getting up early to help feed a lot of hungry boys and manage the ranch (and the occasional loose cow roundup) to daily dusting to keep the country dirt from building up in her home. Occasionally, Gram would grab a cup of coffee with a friend, but most days were consumed by hard work. (After the second or third entry that listed “Ironed for four hours,” Mom gained a brand new appreciation of polyester and synthetics.)
Did my gram deserve a break? Certainly more than most of us working 9 to 5 jobs do. So where does the “I deserve it” mentality come in? You win the prize if you guessed “freakin’ genius marketers.” How do you get people who don’t need more consumer goods and can’t afford them anyway to spend, spend, spend? By proliferating the idea that “you deserve it.”
The Cult of Deserving and the Truth of the Matter
This philosophy is seductive. It’s a pat on the back. It’s a “well done, pal” in a world that doesn’t always recognize our efforts. It’s an ego boost and a way to set yourself apart from everyone else. (Surely Bob in accounting spends more time playing Solitaire than you, you deserve that second cinnamon roll!) But it the end, it’s simply a platitude, and an empty one at that.
Here’s the truth: you do deserve a break. But you deserve better than a break that simply eats at your income and forces you to work longer and harder. You deserve the chance to work hard to reach your dreams, not to be sucked in by a cheap marketing ploy. The next time you’re tempted to splurge on a take-out meal or a new gadget, catch yourself when you say, “I deserve it.” Think of what you truly want in life, and put your energy and money towards that.
photo credit: Mannequin-






This post has 36 comments
September 23rd, 2008
Okay, I take it back. You DON’T deserve a spa day when hubby is all recovered
Emilys last blog post..20 Things I Love About Autumn
September 23rd, 2008
I felt a bit dejected until I got to the end, and then I realised the message was brilliant. So much so, I’m going to do something with that notion today! Thanks Sara.
Dave Fowlers last blog post..Women’s Work: The Hardest Work I’ve Ever Done
September 23rd, 2008
Thank you Sara for this short, well written post that clearly demonstrates the power of marketing and the importance of staying focused on our goals. It’s the marketer’s job to sell us a product or service and they will use just about any means possible. It’s our job to determine the worth of their product or service based on our needs or wants and not theirs. This is an especially timely post for our consumer driven and debt ridden economy. It’s time to set goals and save rather than spend because some marketer says I need a break today.
September 23rd, 2008
I agree. We deserve long term satisfaction breaks not quick fixes that eventually leave us feeling empty.
Stacey / Create a Balances last blog post..Do What You Love
September 23rd, 2008
Love how you closed this one up! Brilliant…
Isn’t sad how we are enslaved by our WANTS?
chriss last blog post..A Thankless Job
September 23rd, 2008
Very good post!!
September 23rd, 2008
This is excellent and awesome. I’ve thought about wants vs. needs a *lot*! In our vast, high-speed, interruption marketing world, it’s very hard to see the difference, and marketers have done an awesome job at blurring the line. It even affects our happiness - “I can’t be happy without this thing!”, even if the thing is something we didn’t know we needed five minutes ago. And we feel deserving of things that we certainly don’t actually deserve.
Thank you! (:
Kyelis last blog post..30-day blog-o-thon: Day 11: SUCCESS! Our blog is now in the top million websites!
September 23rd, 2008
I guess I am one of the few who can say, “Yes, I rounded-up some livestock today!” I live on an organic cattle ranch, so moving the herd is a regular activity. Albeit, I never feel the need to indulge in marketing muckity muck after a cattle drive. I suppose my minimalist lifestyle and absence of television help to keep my pocketbook full.
Squawkfoxs last blog post..Crutches, Magpies, and Tomatoes Oh My!
September 23rd, 2008
Sara,
Thank you for this insightful and thoughtful post. It’s true how much advertising often sells us broken dreams, rather than encouraging us to discover our own dreams and live a true adventure.
David | beplayfuls last blog post..Life is Work
September 23rd, 2008
I get a sense that your grandma probably enjoyed the 4 hours of ironing. I really believe that.
I am so consumed by my kids all day that I have started to enjoy breaks like that. Ironing clothes gives me uninterrupted “me” time AND gets work done …leaving me feeling good inside and out.
What I mean to say is that I think your grandma was just really smart in the way she weaved her breaks into her hard days consumed by chores. Life was a lot “simpler” then without having to deal with all these genius marketing folk …
September 23rd, 2008
This post blew me away… Your analysis is right on. I definitely have a tendency to run to the store and grab a snack or treat when I feel I deserve it. The real reward I should be getting is saving money and taking time for myself to do something I love!
- Jack Rugile
Simple Sapien
Simple Sapiens last blog post..Death By Simplification
September 23rd, 2008
Very thoughtful post.
A prime example of a marketing scheme are the Mastercard “priceless” ads. Working for and achieving your dreams are more “priceless” than plucking down a piece of plastic and going further into debt.
September 23rd, 2008
A wonderful post and very very true. Thank you.
Vals last blog post..Hurricane Ike pictures
September 23rd, 2008
What a great post! I absolutely, 100% agree with you. And I truly think this attitude, which has become a completely accepted platitude, is one of the biggest causes of so many problems in our society today!
We have become a very selfish society. We are taught that “we deserve a break”, “we work hard, we deserve the best”, or my fav (insert sarcasm) “you have to take care of yourself first”.
It is these accepted notions that encourage people to buy more and more even if it has to be purchased on credit. It is these notions that encourage moms or dads to leave their kids, take off, and “find themselves”. Because, you know, YOU are the most important person in the room, not your kids.
And then we wonder what is wrong with our kids today. They are so materialistic, they have no sense of saving, they rarely learn how to work hard to earn what they want, and they are cruel and bullying is worse than ever.
OK, now I know I am off on a bit of a tangent, but I just think we need to stop worrying about taking care of ourselves here and now and worry about taking care of our families, our finances and our long term happiness.
Irenes last blog post..Sneaky methods
September 23rd, 2008
I think you’ve hit on a really important point here - getting deep to the heart of some of the malaise in our world. Well done for writing it in such an informal, non-preachy way.
Joanna Youngs last blog post..Confident Writing Is a Top 10 Writing Blog
September 23rd, 2008
Gooood one!!
Nikkis last blog post..
September 23rd, 2008
Loved your post. “Here’s the truth: you do deserve a break. But you deserve better than a break that simply eats at your income and forces you to work longer and harder” - this is awesome.
Avani-Mehtas last blog post..How To Pick Your First Anger Management Area - Anger Management Series Part IV
September 23rd, 2008
Hi Sara. Yes, marketing certainly has a way of wrapping you around its Big Finger. And usually it’s to help its Big Finger get into your wallet. Deserving is a very strong word. Loved this! Thanks.
Davinas last blog post..I’m Over The Moon As NBOTW
September 23rd, 2008
I so surprised at the positive feedback (pleasantly so)! I actually wrote this months ago and back-burnered it because I thought it came off as too shrill. Thanks for getting what I was trying to say!
Emily: Oh no! Is it too late to take it back?
Dave: That was my worry with this piece, that folks would think I was bashing them over the head. Thanks for making it to the end!
Mark W: “It’s our job to determine the worth of their product or service based on our needs or wants and not theirs.” I agree that we have a role to play in marketing. We’re the final arbiters of what matters, and we have the power to reject marketing messages. (Even if those fries look really tasty…)
Stacey: Bingo! That’s just what I’ve been feeling.
Chris: Thanks so much! It really can be enslavement, when we’re forced to leave our families and do crappy work we hate. I’m glad to have parents who made fun of commercials and trained me early to see the logic problems in them.
Anne: Thanks!
Kyeli: I know what you mean about the “I can’t be happy without this thing” syndrome. The “I deserve it” mentality is just a way to back-door around the lack of logic and lack of need. I’ve been there, and still fight against it.
Squawkfox: Ha! You do deserve a break today! It’s amazing how actually accomplishing something means you don’t have to reward yourself to feel like you spent your time well.
David: I love the way you put that. Why settle for someone else’s dream when you can create your own? Lovely.
Maya: You’ve made a good point, and it’s something I hadn’t thought about. Ironing certainly isn’t my thing, but repetitive, mind-free activities do have a meditative quality. I like your notion that you can combine work and “me” time. Much better than always always assuming that work time is “wasted” time in terms of enjoyment.
Jack: Thanks so much for the kind words. There’s definitely a balance to be found. (Sometimes those tiny treats can turn a rough day around.) But yeah, taking time to do something you love is always a fantastic, lasting reward.
David: Ooh, those are sneaky, and I’m glad you brought up another marketing campaign. The end item always makees those purchases seem worthwhile, while the emotion that the commercial is truly hinting at is nearly always free.
Val: Thanks–I appreciate it.
Irene: Thanks for sharing your thoughts–that’s really what this is all about. I like that you brought it back to long-term happiness. While I do think a bit of self-care can be a good thing (and sometimes a great thing), the ultimate decider is whether your actions are contributing to long-term happiness or short-term panaceas.
Joanna: I’m so glad you mentioned “non-preachy.” I’m not perfect, so I never want to preach, and I was afraid this post had some of that tone it it. You nailed it with the term “malaise.” That’s the root of as many problems as love and money.
Nikki: Thanks!
Avani: I’m so glad you enjoyed this; thanks for letting me know.
September 23rd, 2008
Davina: Perfectly stated!
September 23rd, 2008
Every time I buy something I try to jutify my spending.
It was on sale.
I’ll get my monies worth for sure.
It’ll pay for itself.
It’s what I work for.
I deserve it.
I question my spending now more so than I ever have in the past. It’s amazing how marketers have really gotten inside all of our heads isn’t it.
Excellent post!
Chase Marchs last blog post..A Teacher’s Lunch
September 23rd, 2008
I think I do a good job of this, but then…I think of my grandparents, or my uncle - working on a farm 24/7/365. There were no breaks, there were no luxuries. The days were long. And they never complained.
Or I read your story from above…
It puts things in perspective…
We have an easy life. Compared to many before us. Compared to many today. If we realize this, and think of the potential if we think long-term…where we can be…with an attitude of gratitude.
Lances last blog post..Don’t Ever Give Up
September 23rd, 2008
Chase: It really does get in our heads. I try not to be swayed, but on some level, if I’m a part of popular culture, I’m going to be influenced. We can try to put up a hell of a fight, though!
Lance: That’s kind of what these journals made me think: while I have my own challenges, there are many things I have that are easier. I’m sure your experiences give you a much different baseline than some of the rest of us.
September 23rd, 2008
It’s funny how many little one-liners we’ve been programmed with. I used to wonder why some commercials seemed so dumb. Especially some jeans commercials. Finally, it all made sense. They try to link a feeling to their words and brand.
I actually started to write my rules down one day so I could see which ones still served me. I just wrote down whatever popped into my head …. “it’s great to learn, because knowledge is power” … “you catch more flies with honey than with vinegar” … “a stitch in time saves 9″ … etc.
It reminded me that we can basically fill our head with good stuff … great quotes, great phrases, great role models … etc.
We’re the directors of our minds.
J.D. Meiers last blog post..Spend 75 Percent on Your Strengths
September 23rd, 2008
J.D.: What a wonderful way to turn it around: keep the good stuff. There’s something special about writing stuff down, there’s a magic in the tangibility…
September 23rd, 2008
Hi Sara - My grandparents had a farm, too. Grandma cooked and cleaned all day and into the late evening. When we were kids it was our job to wash dishes when we visited. It was always a joy to see her sit down and enjoy a relaxing moment or two. We loved to wait on her, even though she would fuss about it. They’re wonderful memories.
I love how you took your story about your grandmother and used it to teach us a great lesson in life.
Barbara Swaffords last blog post..NBOTW - Her Spirit Will Move You
September 23rd, 2008
Barbara: Thanks. As I get older, I find more and more ways that I admire her and that some of my weird quirks come straight from her. I’m so happy that you’ve got wonderful memories–keep ‘em close to you!
September 24th, 2008
You post brings what many of us don’t have: balance. We ignore ourselves and our true needs completely, then try to fill the void with material possessions and unhealthy relationships.
Carlas last blog post..Plastic and its health risks
September 24th, 2008
Great sharing through using a story about grandma. The lesson that you bring is much more powerful this way! Thanks!
Evelyn Lims last blog post..Mind Travel To Ancient Egypt
September 24th, 2008
I liked this one, to be really allert to what you really whant and go for that.
Spiritlights last blog post..Dagen i dag!
September 24th, 2008
Well said Sara- these marketers are sneaky. But as you say - we’d be doing ourselves a huge favour by focusing on what we really want instead of wasting our money on junk that will make us feel good for a few minutes.
Cath Lawsons last blog post..Free Gift Ideas That Help You Sell More
September 24th, 2008
Amen. Now I just have to follow it
September 24th, 2008
Even worse. McDonald’s slogan was “Have you had your break today?” Not even that you deserve it, you’re entitled to it.
September 24th, 2008
Carla: That picture is lovely, by the way. And yes, yes, yes! The more I life and think, the more it all comes down to balance. You expressed that beautifully.
Evelyn: I’m so glad you enjoyed hearing about Gram! She pretty much rocks.
Spiritlight: Alertness is a great way to put it–being aware and open to what our gut is telling us.
Cath: That’s how I like to think of it: not as denying myself some treat, but as indulging my deeper whims. Sometimes those crafty marketers still win out, though. When I cave, I try to be sure to enjoy the experience fully.
Therese: Seriously. That’s always the hard part!
Brian: Ack! There is a distinct difference in tone there. It almost comes across as an accusation, as in, “Everybody else has had a fantastic break. Why haven’t you?” Like I’m defective or uptight if I don’t want to!
September 26th, 2008
Well said!
September 27th, 2008
Abbie: Thanks!
Trackbacks
Add a comment