Are Your Collections Pulling Their Weight?
For someone who hates clutter, I have a surprising affinity for collections. There’s something fun about finding something you love and hunting it down mercilessly, followed by basking in the glow of your favorite items. As usual, I think there’s nothing wrong with surrounding yourself with things you honestly value and enjoy. One way to balance the dual passions of clutter-free living and curating a collection is to focus on things that have a true purpose.
From Dolls to Dishes
When I was in my early teens, I first starting to enjoy collecting. It was a way of defining who I was, who I wasn’t, and building something that would last. Like any other teen, I collected music. Unlike any other teen, I also collected Elvis memorabilia, Cinderella paraphernalia, and vintage Barbie reproductions. (If I sound like I was probably an annoying teen, it’s because I was probably a really annoying teen.) There was no harm in it, my room looked awesome, and people always knew what they could get me for a gift. But five years later, all of that Stuff was just sitting around, gathering dust. I grew up out of the style and simply didn’t want Barbies cluttering up my dorm room. They’re still sitting around, now taking up space in my parents’ garage. It’s not that I don’t like them. I just don’t have any use for all of it.

Then, I made a smart decision. I decided that when I was ready to buy real, grown-up dishes, I would get Fiestaware. It’s affordable, it’s durable, and you can constantly switch out colors. It fit my needs perfectly. Once word spread that was “into” Fiesta (it’s like a cult, I swear), I starting receiving it all the time. So instead of getting Elvis trading cards as a gift or cheap plastic Cinderella toys, I ended up with a fully stocked cabinet of everyday dishes. The best part? Just about every color in my cabinet comes with a happy memory or story. That’s another one of the fun parts of collecting; it truly is interactive, and your stuff comes with stories.
Five years later (actually quite a few more), I still use all of those gifts on a daily basis. I’ve broken one Shamrock mug (hey, it had to happen sooner or later) and scratched the hell out of a Cobalt plate. A collection that you use loses just a bit of its magic, but trust me, it’s worth it. A living collection doesn’t take away from your life in the form of hours spent dusting, cleaning, displaying, and fretting. It’s all of the fun, with none of the work or clutter.

Not my dishes; mine are in the dishwasher...
So if you can’t resist the idea of collecting, consider creating a working collection, like:
Dishware
Glassware
Plants and flowers
Cigar boxes/fruit crates/etc (great storage!)
Quilts and blankets
Vintage clothing (that you actually wear, of course)
Recipes (looking for old handwritten recipes is so satisfying)
Music
Jewelry (quite possibly the best souvenir ever!)
Silverware (such a rush to find silver at thrift stores)
Antique furniture
Stationery
What else can you think of?
Before You Go Crazy Collecting…
Here’s one last kicker: you’ve got to actually use the items. Justifying shelves of glass vases only flies if you use your collection. Things to be looked at and not touched aren’t useful. You may love them, keep them, and cherish them for life, but they’re never going to be much more than beautiful Stuff. That’s not bad, but you may want to put serious thought into your decision before beginning a collection like that.
And remember that what you like is totally personal. If collecting coins, stamps, or Hello Kitty tiaras floats your boat, then enjoy your hobby by all means. If the thought of having a collection that provides you with pleasure and use for years to come is more appealing, then consider more useful items that are likely to have long-term value.
Now I’d love to hear it. Other people are way smarter than me: what collections have offered true value in your life? Does collecting serve a purpose, or is it all just overvalued Stuff? Please feel free to share your thoughts in the comments!
Photos courtesy of luisvilla and danagraves






This post has 13 comments
October 15th, 2009
Great post! I collected Barbies for a long time and decided I was tired of their uselessness (rather than just being pretty) last year. I have whittled down my collection to only the most recent that were gifted to me; those will probably go early next year.
I want to collect vintage pyrex, as it is so cute and useful. But those little dishes can be quite a few dollars to buy! I’m still waiting to stumble onto some great pyrex finds at the thrift store.
FrugalChick´s last blog ..Family ties
October 15th, 2009
One thing that people collect that has always baffled me … autographs. What real purpose do they serve? I’ve met many different celebrities in all the airports I’m in, but I’d rather just chat with them than fumble around for some old church bulletin or piece of scratch paper for them to scribble an illegible signature on.
I have NO collections. Really, they serve no purpose.
Ron´s last blog ..Responsibly Managing Your Credit Cards
October 15th, 2009
I collect rare CDs for bands I love. I have a huge collection of CDs for one particular band, but to me, it’s not a waste because I listen to the bonus tracks, acoustic versions, and B-sides on the CDs I collect.
I also have a collection of American Girl Dolls and Tonner Dolls that can’t be displayed in my small apartment right now. I recently sold a card collection because I felt it was just taking up space and wasn’t something I’d ever display.
Like you mentioned in the article, it’s just a lot of fun finding an item you’ve been searching for. But I don’t believe in collecting just for the sake of collecting. You have to love it, otherwise the items are a waste of space (and your money!)
Christine´s last blog ..Items That You No Longer Need or Want – Where Should They Go?
October 15th, 2009
FrugalChick: Have fun with the Pyrex. There really are some steals out there, and the stuff is a lifesaver. I hate having to walk by a Pyrex steal in a thrift store, but I always remind myself that I just don’t need it. May as well leave it there for someone who really loves the stuff, like yourself.
And Ron, you mean standing in line for an autograph from the Nelson brothers (not kidding) was a waste of time? Well, now that you say it….
October 15th, 2009
Another thing I like to keep in mind with collections is that at any point, I can stop collecting the item and still enjoy the collection as it stands.
bashtree´s last blog ..I think I forgot to mention …
October 15th, 2009
I have not collected anything in years. Part of the reason is because as soon assomeone know you like monkeys or Russian dolls or what have you, they start buying you those things for every gift imaginable.
My collection is useful. I have silver and crystal pieces I love and use as often as possible. In fact, I like to use these things for ordinary everyday things. Right now my crystal and silver is being used in a Halloween display. I also got rid of my everyday dishes and use my china – every day.
I heard os a woman who collects hotel dishes which I think would be cool to compliment my china (white with silver and grey).
Great post!
paisleypenguin´s last blog ..Small Things Accomplished
October 15th, 2009
I love, love, love this post. A few years ago, after a difficult summer of losing several relatives and pets, I looked around and realized that the collections I had were meaningless to me. So I got rid of all of it. I didn’t know it but I was clearing space for something of true value to me, something useful. Something I’d always wanted but for some reason wouldn’t let myself have: Fiesta Ware! It makes me happy every day to look at those riotous colors and use it. For years I’d also bemoaned how I’d never inherited any of my grandmother’s McCoy vases, so off I went to Ebay and now I have a lovely collection of five of them. I think of my grandmother every time I look at them, and you know what I discovered? They’re just as good as if I had inherited the real thing from her. Thanks!
Patty – Why Not Start Now?´s last blog ..The Archetype of Relationship
October 16th, 2009
I’ve never collected anything except quotes and books. What does that say about me?!?
I say collect what makes you happy and know when to stop!
October 17th, 2009
I havent had a collection since I was a kid. Basketball cards were my addiction. Maybe I’ll go back to doing that.
October 17th, 2009
I love this post!
I recently had to battle with myself about how I felt about my collections. I decided that if I couldn’t find a way to make them function in my life, I should pass them on.
I have a collection of signed prints, original art, and animation cells. I framed them in ornate frames so that they would seem more “grown-up” even though they are cartoon based.
I also have a My Little Pony collection, which I hide all but a few behind the books on my bookshelf. I keep a few out and rotate them periodically.
I also have many small collections, like coins from around the globe, steampunk ornaments, trashy 50’s novels, feathers, etc. These I artistically arranged in a glass coffee table from Ikea. Now they’ve become conversation pieces when I have parties!
I also just started a collection of antique jewelry.
October 19th, 2009
The only thing I collected as a kid were baseball cards and comics. To this day, I still have them. Is it useful? Not really. In fact, I would say if I ever have kids, I will probably just pass them on.
Thanks for the great post!
Dayne
Dayne | TheHappySelf.com´s last blog ..YOU
October 23rd, 2009
When i travel or go on vacation, if shopping time is included, I find a christmas tree ornament or some souvenir that I can hang on my christmas tree as a reminder of the trip.
They come out on display once a year and hold great memories.
October 25th, 2009
Maybe I’m a little odd, but I’ve never quite figured out what to collect. Not for lack of trying. The only thing I’ve ever really collected was snow globes while I was in college. I do not recommend it. Not only do they take up a lot of space but you need to store the boxes they came in too. Luckily that helped them sell when I decided it was time to move on.
I still want to collect, but I don’t know what. I’ll definitely keep these recommendations in mind as I continue my search!
Wendy´s last blog ..Five posts commented
Trackbacks
Add a comment