What a Pickup Artist Taught Me about Simple Living

When I found a copy of Neil Strauss’s The Game: Penetrating the Secret Society of Pickup Artists in my husband’s books recently, I couldn’t decide whether I was horrified or intrigued. This book, which had its 15 minutes of infamy a few years ago, details the story of a self-professed geek who immerses himself in the seduction community and comes out a master pickup artist. It’s not a pickup guide, though there’s a lot of that in there. And it’s not a moralistic tale, though there’s a lot of that, too. In the end, I was surprised to find the book to be a plea for authenticity–in essence, personal simplicity. There are a ton of different messages you could take away from a book like this, and here’s what resonated with me:
First, meeting and interacting with people is easy. Amazingly easy. Take out the pseudo-hypnotism, the magic tricks, and the canned “routines,” and these pickup gurus have one communication secret: asking another person a question. That’s it. People of both genders are more than willing to start a conversation with you provided you show a modicum of interest in them. I wouldn’t recommend memorizing fake hypotheticals and asking every person in the room if they believe in spells, but if you want to start a conversation, asking for an opinion on something you’re truly curious about is a simple, effective solution.*
Second, all the stuff in the world can’t make you feel worthy. Not a mansion, not an army of weirdo pickup artist followers, and certainly not a pet wallaby. (I’m not kidding.) Throughout the book, Strauss shares stories of men (and women) who are looking to be validated. It’s what drives them into the pickup community, and what makes them chase phone numbers and hookups instead of relationships. What they’re really missing, though, is a sense of inner worth and a support system of genuine friends. Everything else (the “number,” the flashy clothes, the nice car, the devotees) is just noise that gets between you and what is truly satisfying. Trying to buy friends and happiness will eventually make you crazy and/or a megalomaniac. I mean, the person who comes off the most “normal” in this book is Courtney Love, who just wants to make everyone lemonade and muffins. Dude.
Finally, you already have everything you need to be happy and complete. The real trick is surrounding yourself with people psychotic enough to make you appreciate it. Many of the pickup artists profiled in the book turned their lives upside down to fit into an appealing lifestyle. They changed their looks, their habits, their mannerisms, their lifestyle, and their way of thinking. (Oh, and they pay a ton of money to other dudes to do so.) And it gave them everything they’d hoped for: friends, women, and a chance to be an alpha male instead of a target. Here’s the kicker: many of them give it all up in the end and gratefully return to the “dorky” lives they once considered inferior. They’d had happiness and contentment all along. They just needed space, and daily episodes from drama-drunk male divas to appreciate it.
I bet everyone is going to have a different reaction to this—what’s yours?
*And apparently, it works especially well if you wear either platform boots, a shirt with an LCD screen, or a pink cowboy hat. Don’t ask me. No one ever talks to me when I wear my pink cowboy hat.
photo credit: Marxchivist






This post has 15 comments
December 12th, 2008
It sounds like a Wizard of Oz kind of ending … all the pick up artist needed was 15 pieces of flair to remind them it’s OK to be yourself.
I like the point on questions, but I think it’s the intentions that shine through.
I’m a believer in be your own best friend, since everywhere you go, you take you with you.
Great write up and it sounds like the book is a lot more than face value.
J.D.Meiers last blog post..Lessons Learned from Peaceful Warrior
December 12th, 2008
Hi – I enjoyed this post. You could also sum this up with confidence. If we have confidence in ourselves we can do such things (in that way simplicity could be found in confidence). You need the confidence to go for these things, if the confidence in your ability to just talk natural to people and enjoy what you have (rather than striving for more) for example, then that’s the major hurdle overcome.
Nice post thanks.
Chris (from Lifestyle Project)s last blog post..10 Ways to Maximise YOUR Time
December 12th, 2008
Hi Sara – Here in the Twin Cities, we’ve been enthralled with the sordid details of a very notorious businessperson whose entire milieu was recently exposed as a fraud. The bankruptcy trustee’s expense approvals were posted in the newspaper yesterday. The guy “needs” $250,000 per MONTH to sustain his lifestyle. Dig a little further into each item and the misery throughout the family is exposed: addiction treatment, prescription drugs, mortgage and tax payments. On and on.
This guy was considered an alpha at one point. It’s just sad how far removed from a happy reality he traveled. It’s true, as you say, things will never fill the hole in your gut.
Betsys last blog post..SUMMONING SANTAS
December 12th, 2008
I despise “pick-up artists.” They find desperate young men who think that getting more phone numbers in bars and clubs will truly make them happier and more satisfied.
Then they charge these guys a lot of money and teach them how to put on a facade. This act may get a few more phone numbers, but in the long run it drives people away because nobody likes a pretender. And most of their “secrets” are just very basic elements of social science that are available for free online or in much better books.
… And don’t even get me started on the blasphemous use of the word “artist” in their title.
December 12th, 2008
Hate pickup artists. Really hate them. Hate their shallowness almost as much as I hate their assumption that I’m not smart enough to know how they are attempting to manipulate me and others.
For awhile, I had all sorts of fun by busting the pickup artists in one of the more notorious singles bars in Orange County.
For me, as a Asperger, who just doesn’t get this whole social thing as well as the unspoken language of people, and as an engineer by trade and inclination, nothing will ever replace substantial, in depth, authentic conversation.
December 12th, 2008
Interesting take on this! I’ve read part of The Game and found it to be quite intriguing. Like Greg says, the “secrets” are basic elements of social science. But some of the manipulation and tactics used in the book is really horrible.
December 12th, 2008
Thank God I’m married with children. It’s much easier to pick-up groceries than women…LOL
chriss last blog post..I Shall Return
December 12th, 2008
Pick-up Artists have run “game” on me before. I did read that book and am brought back to what I knew all along. Nothing replaces authenticity. No amount of peacocking can substitute for confidence.
December 12th, 2008
Pick up artists are fake and ingenuous. It’s interesting that we can learn how to be real and connect with people from them. How ironic!
I like the message you’ve put forth in this post. Good job!
Chase Marchs last blog post..Sweatshop Union Interview Part 3
December 13th, 2008
I love this post! So funny!
December 21st, 2008
You hit it right on the head, Sara. Having seen many young guys get involved in the “seduction community” (and a short stint of it myself), the ultimate thing we were seeking (and some found) was authenticity–but how so elusive being simply present with whatever is right here can be!
Even amongst those men who directly seek to be more authentic, many end up confusing authenticity for emotional intensity, and thus end up back in ego inflation.
But you’re totally right in that authenticity is simplicity–no tricks, lines, “language patterns,” “conversational hypnosis” or anything like it is truly required of someone coming from the inside-out. Attempting to reproduce the exterior behaviors of someone great at something you want leads to this kind of misunderstanding and over-complexity.
Duffs last blog post..Are You In Control of Your Life?
December 29th, 2008
This is a great post Sara,
It’s so easy to be judgmental and turn your back to marginal ideas and people, like pick-up artists. You don’t do that and try to understand them.
You also come up with great lessons from an unusual, controversial source, which makes this post original and interesting.
I enjoyed this post a lot.
Buraks last blog post..How to Actualize Yourself?
January 8th, 2009
i’ve been reading stuff about venusian arts for a while.. I needed to know where did i go wrong in some conversations i had before with girls and there are a lot of things that makes sense! I disagree when some of you say that when you have a conversation using this tips it won’t be authentic. It’s very easy to be yourself, tell stories that really happened to you while using this so called “techniques”. You don’t have to lie if you don’t want to.. that depends on the person that use it. A lot of it it’s common sense, the books give us quidelines to what to do and not to do when you engage with a stranger you want to chat and meet. I’m portuguese so excuse me if my english isn’t so well writen!
April 29th, 2009
good article about the Pick up artist. They are gamers.
April 30th, 2009
Nice point of view Sara, but truth is, everyone wants to improve the sucess with women. So, I just read this book as a complement to my long-time “game”. And you know what? I´m getting better!
Trackbacks
Add a comment